Chris Albrecht Implodes: Can we go back to the Carnivale?
My favorite television show for the two short years it was on was Carnivale on HBO. The show was, in my opinion, a sterling example of the pinnacle of television story-telling art. It had the quality of a motion picture with the extended and interesting character development that is possible in a serialized teleplay. The richly textured world it created was fascinating. I was pleased that HBO could lavish the attention and resources on the show to make it the glory that it was.
The primary criticism of the first season was that it was too slow, too deliberately paced, that things took too long to develop. I would expect nothing less from the addled attention spans of my peers — I chose to savor it. The second season did pick up the pace a bit, but I felt that they could since they laid such a solid foundation in the first season. Then, in the latter part of the second season, things accelerated, events started happening quickly and, in the season finale, a much-anticipated confrontation occurred and several major plot lines were left unresolved. Shortly thereafter the series was canceled.
Chris Albrecht, CEO of HBO, explained that the show was too expensive for the ratings it received. He marveled at all of the angry emails he received from fans of the program. I canceled my HBO subscription and told the cable company and HBO why: "No Carnivale, no HBO." HBO has since killed Deadwood, another expensive production with sinking ratings and is committed to another $120 million season of Rome, even though ratings aren't great there either.
I thought Carnivale was exactly the sort of "boutique" program that HBO could support for an extended period. At least long enough to tell the whole story and to pick up a passle of Emmys along the way. Does GM make billions on the Corvette? Does Chrysler make billions on the Viper? They are products that draw us in to the show room. A lucky few of us actually get to buy them, the rest of us leave with something decidely less flashy.
Did Albrecht even bother to find out if production costs on the "expensive" Carnivale could be reduced? The rumor is that the show cost $4-5 million per episode. At one point Albrecht said that is the show were a $2 million show it would still be on the air. What gets made for that kind of money today? Is that Arliss money? That piece of crap was on the HBO schedule forever.
While I don't want to indulge in schadenfreude overly, I must say that I hope that Chris Albrecht's recent departure from HBO provides some small sliver of hope that Carnivale might someday return to the schedule. I am shocked that HBO paid hush money years ago the last time Albrecht beat up a woman — I'm pleased that current management has apparently revisited past decisions and decided it would be better if Albrecht wasn't around. Maybe we can convince them to revisit the past decision regarding Carnivale and bring back one of the best shows ever produced for television.
Labels: Carnivale, Chris Albrecht, HBO

